This scrumptious toasted Reuben Sandwich is piled high with Swiss cheese, thin layers of sliced corned beef, sauerkraut, and homemade thousand island dressing all on rye bread. This is the best reuben sandwich and one of mine and hubby’s absolute favorites. This classic sandwich was the brainstorm of Reuben Kulakofsky at the Blackstone Hotel in Omaha, Nebraska in 1914. Serve with homemade potato chips and a dill pickle spear.
If you like the reuben than you must try the Rachel Sandwich with sliced turkey, Swiss cheese, and coleslaw all grilled to perfection like your favorite grilled cheese sandwich.
Why this recipe works?
- This is one of the tastiest sandwiches under the sun. It is always a huge hit with family and friends. You are going to love it.
- These sandwiches are so easy to make that even tweens can handle this recipe. No special techniques or ingredients are required to master this one.
- You can easily scale this recipe for one sandwich or break out a couple of skillets and make enough for the wrestling team.
How do you make a Reuben Sandwich?
Start by mixing all the ingredients for the thousand island dressing together. Next place a slice of Swiss cheese on each slice of bread. Then spread the cheese with the homemade thousand island dressing. Now add the corned beef to one side and the sauerkraut to the other side. If desired spread a little more thousand island dressing.
Then carefully fold the two sides together to form a sandwich. Spread soft butter over the top and place butter side down in a hot nonstick skillet over medium heat. Now spread butter over the side facing up. Cover the skillet loosely with aluminum foil. Cook until both bead slices are golden brown flipping halfway through. The sandwich should be heated through and the cheese should be melted.
Recipe notes and helpful tips
- Use good quality dark rye bread, pumpernickel or a rye/pumpernickel blend or swirl.
- Drain the sauerkraut well and squeeze or press against the side of the colander to release any excess moisture. No one likes a soggy sandwich.
- Put the cheese on the bread first as this helps the cheese melt better by being close to the heating element and it also helps keep the bread from getting soggy.
- Ask the deli counter to slice the corned beef thin. I like the corned beef sliced thin so the swiss and homemade thousand island dressing can meld in between the slices.
- The sandwich is often made with Russian dressing in place of the thousand island dressing. Russian dressing has horseradish and Worcestershire sauce which thousand island does not. Thousand Island has pickle relish while Russian dressing does not.
- Protip – microwave the corned beef for about 45 seconds at 50% power to take the chill off. You don’t want to cook it you just want to ensure that your sandwich is heated all the way through and is one glorious hot mess.
- The dressing can be made up to several days in advance.
- Cover the skillet loosely with aluminum foil so the whole sandwich warms all the way through and cheese melts perfectly.
Other sandwiches you will love!
Classic Reuben Sandwich Recipe
The homemade thousand island dressing takes this Reuben Sandwich over the top. Better than your favorite deli reuben this sandwich hits the sweet spot just right.
- Prep Time: 5 minutes
- Cook Time: 10 minutes
- Total Time: 15 minutes
- Yield: 4 servings
- Category: lunch, dinner
- Method: stovetop
- Cuisine: American
Ingredients
Thousand Island Dressing
- ½ cup mayonnaise
- 2 tablespoons grated onion
- 2 tablespoons ketchup
- 2 tablespoons sweet pickle relish
- 1 pinch paprika
- 1 pinch salt
Sandwiches
- 12 ounces corned beef
- 8 slices rye (or rye and pumpernickel mixed)
- 8 slices swiss cheese
- 1 cup sauerkraut (well drained)
- 4 tablespoons butter
Instructions
- In a small bowl mix the mayonnaise, grated onion, ketchup, sweet pickle relish, paprika, and salt together.
- Place a piece of Swiss cheese on each slice of bread. Then spread about 1 tablespoon of dressing over each slice of bread. Add the corned beef to four of those slices of bread dividing evenly. Add the sauerkraut to the other four slices of bread dividing evenly. Carefully fold the corned beef sides to the sauerkraut sides to form 4 sandwiches.
- Spread soft butter over the top of each sandwich. Place the sandwich butter side down in a hot skillet over medium low heat. Spread butter over the side facing up. Cover the skillet loosely with aluminum foil. Cook until the bottom is golden brown then flip. Cover and cook until the other side is golden brown. The sandwich should be heated through and the cheese should be melted.
Keywords: how to make a reuben sandwich, corned beef sandwich, what is a reuben sandwich, corned beef reuben
On the hunt for more delicious recipes? Follow Small Town Woman on Facebook, Pinterest, and Instagram.
https://www.smalltownwoman.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/Beth-1.pdf
Teresa from Alexandria
I tried this recipe for the first time today, St Paddy’s day, and maybe I used the wrong pan, but the first one just stuck to it, turned into a mess, which my daughter ended up eating with a fork. She still loved it! I made mine with a panini pan and it turned out awesome and much easier to eat.
Rose
This was wonderful! I’ve made Reubens before but the dressing was always a bit off, but this was perfect! It’s the grated onion that makes it so amazing. Mu husband loved it and he is super picky. I also asked the deli to make the corned beef extra thin and used Boar’s Head. This really is the perfect recipe. Thank you!
★★★★★
Beth Pierce
Thanks so much Rose! The pleasure was all mine. So glad that you and your husband liked it. I just love Reubens!
Jacque Hooper
Enjoyed this for lunch today and it does not disappoint! Better than anything I have had from a deli; easily, a new favorite sandwich!
★★★★★
Jessie
Wow this reuben looks so amazing!! This is a must try soon.
★★★★★
AISilva
This reuben sandwich looks so good, I can’t wait to try it! My kids won’t be able to resist the melted cheese and thousand island dressing. Even better that it can be done in 15 minutes. Thank you!
★★★★★
Amanda Dixon
This was the best reuben! It had the perfect balance of melted cheese and saucy dressing to make one truly decadent sandwich. Will definitely make again!
★★★★★
Ashley F.
The homemade dressing is amazing on this! Loved it!
★★★★★
Suzy
The best and tastiest sandwich around! We loved it!
★★★★★
Maria
What a very comforting dish! Definitely going to my bookmarks. I need to make this ASAP
★★★★★
Wanda
This sandwich looks like it is is oozing with goodness! I’ve never had a reuben before and can’t wait to try this recipe!
★★★★★
Wilma
This recipe is fantastic! Only thing I do differently is brown my buttered bread first, then add dressing and cheese, I heat the krout and corn beef on a griddle then add it to my bread. That way everything is hot and all so good!
Michelle
I’ve always wanted to make a reuben but didn’t know how until I came across your recipe! It turned out amazing, thanks for sharing!
★★★★★
Dannii
This is such a sandwich classic, but I have made it myself. I am definitely going to have to try it.
★★★★★
Jo
Definitely the best Reuben sandwich recipe I ever tried! My family really enjoyed it!
★★★★★
Vicky
I brown one side, flip and shove into a 400 dg. oven to brown the other side and melt the cheese.
Toni
My kids really loved this sandwich! I will definitely make it again!
★★★★★
Kristyn
I love the homemade dressing! I need to keep that on hand! It goes perfect in this sandwich! I’m wishing I had one right in front of me! Time to get more ingredients!
★★★★★
Sara Coleman
This is my husband’s favorite! He just asked me to make it again for him!
★★★★★
Beth Pierce
Thanks Sara! So glad that he likes it!!
Sara Welch
Always a fan of a Reuben Sandwich, but this takes the cake! So delicious and hearty; worthy of a restaurant, indeed!
★★★★★
Kristyn
Cheesy, oozing goodness!! Now, this is a sandwich my hubby craves all the time!! Super simple & great with so many sides!
★★★★★
Katie
Looks so good! Can’t wait to try this one with my family!
★★★★★
Claudia Lamascolo
my all-time favorite made super easy! I am all over this one! Thanks!
★★★★★
Kim Guzman
That dressing is simply divine. It really made this sandwich. A dill pickle and French fries on the side. Yum!
★★★★★
Noelle Simpson
Yum! I forgot how much I enjoyed reuben sandwiches until I made this! Saving to make again soon!
★★★★★
Cate
Such a classic lunch sandwich, and yours looks incredible! Saving this to make soon!
Catalina
This sandwich looks so inviting! So perfect for my quick lunches!
★★★★★
Allyson Zea
This is such a classic sandwich, and I love the combination of these flavors!
Beti | easyweeknightrecipes
This Reuben Sandwich looks incredibly delicious!! I am so excited to try it!
★★★★★
katerina @ diethood.com
This Reuben Sandwich is amazing!! Everyone loved it!
★★★★★
Jen
I took your advice and had my teen make these for us for dinner. They were a huge hit! So delicious.
★★★★★
Erin | Dinners,Dishes and Dessert
This toasted Reuben Sandwich is looks absolutely tasteful!
★★★★★
Dorothy Reinhold
One of my very favorite sandwiches! Your tip about heating of the corned beef is SOOO smart!